Mojo - 3 stars out of 5 -- "[With] 'Lifelong Passion' and 'Don't Stop Running,' tracks that make the best of McCartney's crystalline vocals and co-producer Youth's way with texture and sound."
Rolling Stone - 4 stars out of 5 -- "The set peaks with 'Travelling Light,' a magical mystery tour of reverbed chants, slide-guitar swoops, kalimbas and chimes. It's freak folk by a forefather."
Spin - 3.5 stars out of 5 -- "ARGUMENTS follows its own fuzzy logic from swamp blooze to haunted folk to anthemic guitar pop."
Entertainment Weekly - "[T]his one studs its chilled-out world-beat electronica with pretty psych-folk melodies, propulsive rock grooves, and McCartney's raw 'Helter Skelter'-ish vocals." -- Grade: B+
Record Collector - 4 stars out of 5 -- "'Two Magpies' is a mouth-watering slice of homegrown 'Honey Pie,' while 'Lifelong Passion' sounds like he's pulled over on George Harrison's 'Blue Jay Way.'"
Billboard - "[I]t's the first Fireman album to include McCartney's vocals. And with his voice on 'Electric ARguments' comes a much more diverse, song-based, pop/rock-oriented approach..."
Rovi
The Fireman is the electronic side project of Paul McCartney and Martin Glover AKA Youth (the founding member of Killing Joke and 1998 Producer Of The Year for his work on The Verve's 'Urban Hymns'). Their third album, 'Electric Arguments' is their first to feature the former Beatle's distinctive vocals and includes the single 'Lifelong Passion'.|
Rovi
ポール・マッカートニーとユースによるユニットが放った10年ぶりの新作は、全曲ヴォーカル入りになったせいか、以前と比べてかなりポップな聴き心地だ。とはいえ、硬質なギター・ソロやスペイシーな4つ打ちを随所に配し、本プロジェクトの持ち味であるアヴァンギャルドな一面もしっかり残している。例えるならば、ポールが住むアイルランドの牧場にユースがUFOに乗って遊びに来た感じ!? ラフなムードも楽しくて最高!
bounce (C)赤瀧 洋二
タワーレコード(2008年12月号掲載 (P79))