Best Of '99-'06

he science of power pop is inexact, but when it is done well, it is cause for celebration. Such is the case with this compilation of songs that Smash Palace shined on but never quite met millions of ears. The bouncy, poppy, jangle-riddled, and infectious songs rarely falter, whether it is the pleasing "Death of Me," the opening "Thinking About Her" (which falls somewhere between Sloan and Crowded House), or the looser, funkier groove of "Steal Her Thunder." Meanwhile, the group slows things down somewhat for "Dime Store Lies," which resembles a smart and poppy midtempo tune by the Odds with sweet harmonies. But often, Smash Palace seem at their best when they add a dash of Americana to their power pop base, as is the case with the roots-leaning "Juliet to Me" and the warm and folksy "Blue Eyes." A retro-pop feel oozes out of the pretty nugget "Sooner or Later," which brings the Kinks in their early heyday to mind. However, when the band tries a bit too hard or forces the issue, as during "Like I Do," it's neither a horrible nor a beautiful result. And when the band decides to up the ante a bit with "I'll Be There," the result is nearly perfect summer driving music with a gorgeous hook from start to finish. Although the bandmembers have aged, Smash Palace's music is quite timeless, especially the rather ragged and raw "In My World Tonight." ~ Jason MacNeil|